Short answer
CFA Level 3 constructed response questions are driven by a bolded command word. Calculate wants a number, Determine and Identify want a conclusion, Justify wants the conclusion plus the case fact that supports it, and Explain, Discuss and Recommend want reasoning. Below are six original examples, one per command word, each with a model answer written to the length graders expect.
Searching for “CFA essay” examples turns up plenty of strategy advice and very few complete examples. This page is the opposite: six short questions across the Level 3 core curriculum, each built around a different command word, with the answer you would actually type. Only Level 3 has essay questions. Levels 1 and 2 are entirely multiple choice.
All questions are original Clevency practice questions in the Level 3 style, not past CFA Institute exam questions. They are drawn from the core topics every candidate sits, whichever pathway you choose.
On this page
What each command word asks for
| Command word | What earns the points | Typical length |
|---|---|---|
| Calculate | The correct number. Steps can earn partial credit if the number is wrong | Formula, inputs, result |
| Determine / Identify / Select | The correct conclusion | A word, a phrase or one line |
| Justify | The conclusion plus the specific case fact or principle that supports it | One or two sentences per point |
| Explain / Describe | The mechanism: why or how something happens | Two or three sentences |
| Discuss | The relevant considerations, linked to the case | A short paragraph |
| Recommend | A clear choice, usually followed by Justify | Choice, then reason |
When a question pairs two words, such as “Determine … Justify”, each half carries its own points. For a fully graded walk-through of what happens when a candidate answers only half, see our graded Level 3 essay question example.
1. Calculate: futures and portfolio beta
Case. Lena Park manages a $50 million equity portfolio with a beta of 0.90. Ahead of a period she expects to be strong for equities, she wants to raise the portfolio beta to 1.20 using equity index futures without trading the underlying stocks. The futures price is 4,000, the contract multiplier is 250 and the futures beta is 1.00.
Calculate the number of futures contracts Park should trade, and state whether she should buy or sell them.
Show model answer
Model answer:
Contract value = 4,000 × 250 = $1,000,000.
N = [(βT − βP) ÷ βF] × (VP ÷ contract value) = [(1.20 − 0.90) ÷ 1.00] × (50,000,000 ÷ 1,000,000) = 0.30 × 50 = 15 contracts. Buy (long), because the target beta is higher than the current beta.
Why it scores: the number and direction are both stated. Common errors are dividing by the futures price without the multiplier (giving 3,750 contracts) and forgetting that raising beta means buying futures.
2. Determine: choosing an options strategy
Case. A client holds a large position in a stock that has risen steadily. She expects the price to stay roughly flat for the next six months, wants to generate additional income from the position, and is willing to give up gains above the current price.
Determine the most appropriate options strategy for the client.
Show model answer
Model answer: A covered call: write (sell) call options on the shares she already owns.
Why it scores: “Determine” only asks for the conclusion, so one line is a complete answer. A protective put would add downside protection at a cost, which is the opposite of generating income, and a collar is unnecessary because she has not asked for downside protection. Writing a paragraph on all three earns nothing extra.
3. Justify: selecting a strategic allocation
Case. A family foundation needs a nominal return of at least 6.5% a year and must keep at least 10% of assets in cash or instruments that can be sold within a week to fund grants. Its consultant proposes two allocations:
| Allocation X | Allocation Y | |
|---|---|---|
| Expected return | 7.1% | 6.8% |
| Expected standard deviation | 11.5% | 10.2% |
| Assets saleable within one week | 6% | 14% |
Determine which allocation is most appropriate. Justify your response.
Show model answer
Model answer: Allocation Y. It meets the 6.5% return requirement (6.8%) and the 10% liquidity requirement (14%). Allocation X has a higher expected return but holds only 6% in liquid assets, which breaches the liquidity constraint.
Why it scores: the justification names the constraint that eliminates X, using the case numbers. A justification of “Y has lower risk” is true but is not the deciding fact, and graders look for the reason that actually drives the choice. Constraints are screened first; among allocations that pass, risk and return are then compared.
4. Recommend: implementing a passive mandate
Case. A $20 million pension sub-portfolio must track a small-cap index of about 2,000 stocks. Many of the smaller constituents are thinly traded and expensive to buy and sell.
Recommend whether the manager should use full replication or stratified sampling. Justify your response.
Show model answer
Model answer: Stratified sampling. With a small portfolio and roughly 2,000 constituents, many of them illiquid, holding every stock would mean many small, costly positions. Sampling from each stratum (for example by sector and size) can match the index’s main characteristics at lower trading cost, accepting some tracking error.
Why it scores: it makes a clear choice and ties it to the two case facts (portfolio size and constituent liquidity). Full replication suits indexes with fewer, liquid constituents and portfolios large enough to hold them all efficiently.
5. Explain: choosing a return measure
Case. A pension fund adds and withdraws money from its external equity manager several times a year, based on the fund’s own cash needs. The manager has no say over the timing or size of these flows.
Explain why the time-weighted rate of return is more appropriate than the money-weighted rate of return for evaluating the manager.
Show model answer
Model answer: The money-weighted return is affected by the timing and size of external cash flows, so it would reward or penalise the manager for decisions made by the pension fund. The time-weighted return removes the effect of those flows by linking sub-period returns, so it measures only the manager’s investment decisions, which is what the evaluation should reflect.
Why it scores: “Explain” needs the mechanism, not just the conclusion. The answer says what each measure captures and connects that to who controls the cash flows in the case.
6. Identify: an Ethics violation
Case. A portfolio manager decides to buy a mid-cap stock for all of her discretionary client accounts. Before placing the client block order, she buys the same stock in her personal account, reasoning that her order is too small to move the price.
Identify the CFA Institute Standard of Professional Conduct most likely violated. Justify your response.
Show model answer
Model answer: Standard VI(B) Priority of Transactions. Client transactions must take priority over personal transactions. She traded for her own account before clients, using knowledge of a pending client order; whether her order moved the price does not matter.
Why it scores: it names the Standard precisely and states the action that breaches it. The size of the order is a distractor built into the case.
How to practise with these
- Write first, then compare. Type your answer before opening the model. Reading model answers without writing your own trains recognition, not production.
- Grade yourself per element. For each part, ask: did I give the conclusion, and did I give the reason the command word asked for?
- Count your words. If your answer is three times longer than the model, you are spending time the exam does not reward.
- Do item sets too. Half the exam is still multiple choice; our Level 3 sample item sets cover that format.
Frequently asked questions
Which CFA level has essay questions?
Only Level 3. Levels 1 and 2 are entirely multiple choice. Level 3 has 11 constructed response (essay) sets and 11 item sets across two sessions.
What are command words in CFA Level 3 essays?
They are the bolded verbs in each question, such as Calculate, Determine, Justify, Explain and Recommend. Each tells you what the graders will award points for.
How long should a CFA Level 3 essay answer be?
As short as the command word allows. Determine can be one line, Justify is usually one or two sentences per point, and Calculate needs the inputs and the result.
Is a correct number enough for a Calculate question?
Yes. CFA Institute awards full credit for a correct numerical answer. Showing your steps is still useful because it can earn partial credit if the final number is wrong.
Are these CFA Level 3 constructed response examples from past exams?
No. They are original practice questions written in the Level 3 style. Official examples are available through CFA Institute's practice materials.
Do essay questions appear in the pathway section too?
Yes. Constructed response and item sets can cover both the core topics and your chosen pathway. Topics are placed randomly across the two sessions.
Related Reading
- CFA Level 3 Essay Question Example, Graded — Three answers to one question, scored
- CFA Level 3 Essay Sample Questions — IPS, behavioural bias and hedging cases
- CFA Level 3 Pathways — Which pathway fits your career